Faulty Grocery Store Scales
“Faulty Grocery Store Scales Leave New Yorkers Paying the Price.”
City inspectors found hundreds of broken or miscalibrated food scales in local supermarkets and grocery stores, records show. But there aren’t enough inspectors to keep up with mandatory annual checks.
…Every time you grab a salad, fruit or steak from a New York City grocery or supermarket, you’re putting your trust in a scale.
Some merchants are sorely testing that trust: City inspectors found hundreds of broken or miscalibrated food scales at groceries and supermarkets between 2023 and 2025, a NYCity News Service analysis of records found. Among the violators were Gristedes, Westside Market and Whole Foods stores.
Faulty scales could lead to overcharging customers, hitting New Yorkers where it hurts amid rising food prices and threats to SNAP benefits. City inspection reports don’t specify whether scales are over- or underestimating the weight of food, but some shoppers are almost certainly paying more than they should.
And despite a wave of recent inspector hires that boosted the ranks to 62 — among them, 34 whose duties include scale inspections — city officials say they currently cannot check every scale annually as required, due to the sheer number of businesses that use the devices.
The NYCity News Service’s analysis of inspection data found that, between 2023 and 2025, DCWP inspectors visited more than 4,000 grocery stores. Nearly a quarter of groceries were cited for at least one violation and inspectors confiscated 100 scales.
In supermarkets, the numbers were even worse: 36% of nearly 1,000 inspected received scale violations. Fifty-seven supermarkets had at least one scale confiscated, while DCWP logged 300 related customer complaints. In total, 11% of inspected scales were marked as “condemned,” requiring the business to fix or replace them before putting them back into service.
The agency classifies grocers differently than supermarkets. Supermarkets are larger and have additional requirements, such as pricing each individual item and providing scanners throughout the store for customer price-checking.
More Information at:
Faulty Grocery Store Scales Leave New Yorkers Paying the Price
